On December 15, 2025, the Georgia Board of Pardons and Parole put a hold on the execution of Stacey Humphreys and postponed his clemency hearing, originally scheduled for December 16, “indefinitely.” Mr. Humphreys was to be executed December 17 — despite claims that his trial was tainted by what three Supreme Court justices described as “extreme juror misconduct.” He was the first person scheduled for execution in Georgia in 2025.
Last week, Mr. Humphreys’ attorneys petitioned Fulton County Superior Court asking that two of the five members of the parole board recuse themselves from considering his clemency petition, citing potential conflicts of interest. One board member was a victim advocate assigned to one of the victims in Mr. Humphreys’ case and another was the sheriff in the town where Mr. Humphreys’ trial was held. According to Mr. Humphreys’ attorneys, just recusing the two members would not be sufficient to ensure his clemency petition received a fair hearing. They argue the two should be replaced so that Mr. Humphreys’ case is heard by a full five-member board without conflicts of interest.
Mr. Humphreys was accused of forcing two realtors to undress at gunpoint inside a model home, then robbing and murdering both women. During jury selection, defense attorneys screened potential jurors for anyone whose similar experience might affect their ability to fairly evaluate the case. One potential juror, Ms. Chancey, reported that she had been the victim of a harrowing attack; she told the court that a convicted murderer, on the run from a mental institution, had broken into her home. However, she assured the court that she could be a fair juror despite that experience and would “honestly consider” all sentencing options. She said that she had managed to escape before the attacker entered her home. She was placed on the jury.