In a November 17, 2026, op-ed published in The Guardian, Annie and Jess Nichol, the sisters of Polly Klaas, who was abducted and murdered in 1993 at the age of 12, said that for more than 30 years, their sister’s case has been cited to justify California’s death penalty. They wrote that they want to make clear where they stand: they do not support the death penalty. The Nichol sisters wrote that they recently met with Governor Gavin Newsom at the former death row at San Quentin to explain their position. Gov. Newsom has since said the conversation helped shape his decision to commute California’s death sentences to life without the possibility of parole, a step the sisters say they embrace as “a critical step toward a more just system.” 

The sisters argue that the death penalty fails the families it claims to serve. Polly’s murderer was sentenced to death but remains on death row three decades later, and they say such a sentence does not bring closure. Instead, it ties families to years of hearings, filings, and headlines, keeping them connected to the person who harmed them. They noted that while they have not forgiven their sister’s killer and “still feel moments of intense grief and anger,” the “vengeance so many survivors experience — however understandable — should not be the basis for public policy.”

“For many of us, the long arc of healing creates the space to ask deeper questions about what justice would actually require: what might help us recover, what could prevent another person from experiencing the same harm, and what forms of accountability might be possible.”

Annie and Jess Nichol, sisters of Polly Klaas, on what victims of violent crime may need. 

The Nichol sisters criticized the way the criminal legal system treats survivors, writing that survivors’ needs vary widely, yet punishment is offered as “a one-size-fits-all” answer in place of “the far more complicated work of healing, accountability and prevention.” Noting that “fewer than one in five survivors” in California receive counseling, medical assistance or financial support, they said many are left with punishment as the only form of justice they are told to expect. On costs, the sisters pointed to non-partisan analyses estimating that ending the death penalty in practice and converting death sentences to life without parole could save California taxpayers up to $150 million a year. They urged this money to be used elsewhere:

“Imagine what $150m a year could do if we invested it in the programs that actually prevent harm: mental health treatment, substance use intervention, gun violence prevention, trauma recovery centers, and support for survivors navigating the long aftermath of violence.” They closed by arguing that Polly’s name should not settle the debate about the death penalty. In their words, the system is “borrowing our pain to justify what it already intended to do.” 

They closed by arguing that Polly’s name should not settle the debate about the death penalty. In their words, the system is “borrowing our pain to justify what it already intended to do.” 

Citation Guide

Sources

Annie Nichol and Jess Nichol, Polly Klaas’ murder is routinely used to justify the death penalty. As her sisters, we oppose it, The Guardian, November 17, 2026.