Law Enforcement

Deterrence & Murder of Police Officers - According to sta­tis­tics from the lat­est FBI Uniform Crime Report, regions of the coun­try that use the death penal­ty the least are the safest for police offi­cers. Police are most in dan­ger in the south, which accounts for 80% of all exe­cu­tions (90% in 2000). From 1989 – 1998, 292 law enforce­ment offi­cers were felo­nious­ly killed in the south, 125 in the west, 121 in the mid­west, and 80 in the north­east, the region with the fewest exe­cu­tion — less than 1%. The three lead­ing states where law enforce­ment offi­cers were felo­nious­ly killed in 1998 were California, the state with the high­est death row pop­u­la­tion (7); Texas, the state with the most exe­cu­tions since 1976 (5); and Florida, the state that is third high­est in exe­cu­tions and in death row pop­u­la­tion (5). (FBI, Uniform Crime Reports, Law Enforcement Officers Killed and Assaulted, 1998

A 1994 study of the deter­rence val­ue of the death penal­ty focused on whether the death penal­ty deterred the mur­der of police offi­cers. The researchers sur­veyed a thir­teen year peri­od of police homi­cides. The study con­clud­ed ” we find no con­sis­tent evi­dence that cap­i­tal pun­ish­ment influ­enced police killings dur­ing the 1976 – 1989 peri­od.… [P]olice do not appear to have been afford­ed an added mea­sure of pro­tec­tion against homi­cide by cap­i­tal pun­ish­ment.” (W. Bailey and R. Peterson, Murder, Capital Punishment, and Deterrence: A Review of the Evidence and an Examination of Police Killings, 50 Journal of Social Issues 5371 1994)

Law Enforcement Officers Feloniously Killed 1989 – 1998

South
Total  292 
1998  29 
1997  32 
1996  24 
1995  32 
1994  24 
1993  31 
1992  28 
1991  29 
1990  31 
1989  32 
West
Total  125 
1998  14 
1997  15 
1996  6 
1995  23 
1994  18 
1993  11 
1992  13 
1991  7 
1990  9 
1989  9 
Midwest
Total  121 
1998  10 
1997  11 
1996  15 
1995  8 
1994  16 
1993  11 
1992  8 
1991  20 
1990  14 
1989  8 
Northeast
Total  80 
1998  3 
1997  7 
1996  10 
1995  8 
1994  12 
1993  9 
1992  8 
1991  7 
1990  7 
1989  9
Total  1998  1997  1996  1995  1994  1993  1992  1991  1990  1989 
South 292  29  32  24  32  24  31  28  29  31  32 
West 125  14  15  6  23  18  11  13  7  9  9 
Midwest 121  10  11  15  8  16  11  8  20  14  8 
Northeast 80  3  7  10  8  12  9  8  7  7  9

On the Front Line: Law Enforcement Views on the Death Penalty 1995 nation­al sur­vey of police chiefs from around the coun­try dis­cred­its the repeat­ed asser­tion that the death penal­ty is an impor­tant law enforcement tool.

Criminologists’ Views

A sur­vey of experts from the American Society of Criminology, the Academy of Criminal Justice Sciences, and the Law
and Society Association showed that the over­whelm­ing major­i­ty did not believe that the death penal­ty is a proven deter­rent to homi­cide. Over 80% believe the exist­ing research fails to sup­port a deter­rence jus­ti­fi­ca­tion for the death penal­ty. Similarly, over 75% of those polled do not believe that increas­ing the num­ber of exe­cu­tions, or decreas­ing the time spent on death row before exe­cu­tion, would pro­duce a gen­er­al deter­rent effect. (M. Radelet and R. Akers, Deterrence and the Death
Penalty: The Views of the Experts, 1995)

Brutalization

Research report­ed in Homicide Studies, Vol. 1, No.2, May 1997, indi­cates that exe­cu­tions may actu­al­ly increase the num­ber of mur­ders, rather than deter mur­ders. Prof. Ernie Thomson at Arizona State University report­ed a bru­tal­iz­ing effect from an exe­cu­tion in Arizona, con­sis­tent with the results of a sim­i­lar study in Oklahoma.

Deaths of Children in the US: New Report — Apparently, the US’s use of the death penal­ty is not improv­ing its stand­ing in the world com­mu­ni­ty when it comes to the deaths of chil­dren. In a February 7, 1997 Report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (part of U.S Dept. of Health and Human Services), from 1950 – 1993 child homi­cide rates in the U. S. tripled. CDC com­pared the U.S. with 25 oth­er indus­tri­al­ized coun­tries and found that the United States has the high­est rates of child­hood homi­cide, sui­cide, and firearm-relat­ed death among indus­tri­al­ized coun­tries.” Almost all of these oth­er indus­tri­al­ized coun­tries have stopped using the death penal­ty The report found that: 

  • The over­all firearm-relat­ed death rate among U.S. chil­dren less than 15 years of age was 12 times high­er than among chil­dren in the oth­er 25 countries combined. 
  • The firearm-relat­ed homi­cide rate in the U.S. was near­ly 16 times high­er than in all of the oth­er countries combined. 
  • The firearm-relat­ed sui­cide rate was near­ly 11 times higher. 

The report not­ed that pre­vi­ous stud­ies have shown an asso­ci­a­tion between rates of vio­lent child­hood death and low fund­ing for social pro­grams, eco­nom­ic stress relat­ed to par­tic­i­pa­tion of women in the labor force, divorce, eth­nic-lin­guis­tic het­ero­gene­ity, and social accept­abil­i­ty of vio­lence. (Rates of Homicide, Suicide, and Firearm-Related Death Among Children — 26 Industrialized Countries, 46 Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 101 (Feb 71997)) 

In com­par­ing the rate of death by hand­guns in eight indus­tri­al­ized coun­tries, the United States stands out with a rate of death by hand­guns that is much high­er than the rate of oth­er coun­tries. The United States is also the only coun­try of the eight to retain use of the death penal­ty. In most for­eign coun­tries, gun con­trol laws are more restric­tive and gun own­ers are assigned more respon­si­bil­i­ty. (Washington Post, 4/​4/​98)