Within three weeks of each other, jury selection began in two uncommon and high-profile capital trials: in a federal death penalty trial in Buffalo, New York, and in a military commission capital trial at Guantánamo Bay. Federal prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Payton Gendron, who killed 10 Black people in a race-based shooting at a Buffalo supermarket in 2022, and for Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, accused of masterminding the 2000 U.S.S. Cole bombing that killed 17 U.S. servicemembers.
Payton Gendron
Jury selection in the case of Mr. Gendron began on October 13, 2026, with the federal trial court seeking to seat jurors from a narrowed pool of about 700 people. 12 jurors and six alternate jurors will be selected after a process that may take between six and eight weeks. In January 2024, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) announced that it would seek a federal death sentence for Mr. Gendron, who has already pled guilty and been sentenced under New York law to multiple life without parole sentences.
The potential jurors answered both group and individual questions about their beliefs on the death penalty. One potential juror told the court that she “couldn’t mentally handle” watching videos of the attack. One woman who spoke to the press after being dismissed from the jury pool said she could not vote to sentence Mr. Gendron to death after hearing about Tennessee’s botched execution of Christa Pike. “I was taken aback by that…I was conflicted before, but after that botched execution, [the death penalty] almost seems barbaric.” She added that “[e]ven though there would be proof of what this person has done, and that it was premeditated…and that it was a heinous crime and the community is still suffering…I don’t think I could condemn someone to death.” Pursuant to a process known as “death qualification,” people who are unwilling to impose a death sentence are legally ineligible to participate in a capital trial.
Over 19 days of questioning, both prosecutors and defense counsel have questioned hundreds of people, with the vast majority of them white. Judge Lawrence Vilardo said he expects Mr. Gendron’s trial to begin in December and last into February 2027. Mr. Gendron is facing 27 federal charges related to the shooting, 20 of which could carry a federal death sentence.
This was the first and only capital case authorized by Attorney General Merrick Garland and the Biden Administration’s Department of Justice (DOJ). Although New York does not have the death penalty, the federal government has jurisdiction to seek the death penalty in any state in the country pursuant to a federal statute.
Mr. Gendron was 18 when he posted on social media about his intentions to kill Black people and then traveled to Buffalo armed with a semiautomatic rifle. Family victims’ family members have not been unified about whether the DOJ should seek a federal death sentence. At his sentencing hearing on state charges, Mr. Gendron expressed remorse for his actions and apologized to the victims’ families. He also offered to plead guilty to the federal charges in exchange for a life sentence without the possibility of parole, but the DOJ rejected this offer. Capital trials typically take many weeks and costs taxpayers millions of dollars in prosecution, defense, security, and court costs.
Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri
Jury selection in the case of Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri began on November 2, 2026, with the Guantánamo Bay Military Commissions court questioning the first 18 potential jurors from a pool of about 200 military officers. The officers were selected from U.S. military bases across the globe, and an additional 18 officers are expected to arrive for questioning in two weeks. Judge Colonel Matthew Fitzgerald has told potential jurors that the trial could last four to six months or longer.
The court must empanel 12 jurors and six alternates, a process which will take several weeks. After the first two weeks, six jurors have been empaneled, including two Army Reserve officers and two Air Force officers. One of the seated Air Force officers told defense counsel he wanted to serve on the jury because “[n]o matter what happens, this is a first,” calling the trial “historic.” Judge Fitzgerald later seated a Navy officer who told the court during questioning that he researched the Military Commissions and finds them “corrupt and morally bankrupt,” adding that he is morally opposed to the conditions of confinement at Guantánamo Bay, which he considers “a very sketchy place.” The officer added that he did not really know what happens at the base, stating “[t]here may be torture that happens here and different threats.” He added that he does not “believe that torture is just and it’s not constitutional and not adherent to the oaths [he] took as a military officer.” Ultimately, the officer reiterated that he had “a long-held belief as to neutrality on the death penalty” and could be impartial.
An Army major was also empaneled after indicating, along with nine other officers, that after spending “20 years at Guantánamo, Mr. al-Nashiri must be guilty of something.” He indicated he is not opposed to the death penalty and agreed with prosecutors that he would have a duty to follow the judge’s instructions and make decisions based on the law. A lieutenant colonel with the Army was dismissed because of his involvement in the U.S.’s operation to capture or kill Osama bin Laden, who is named as Mr. al-Nashiri’s alleged co-conspirator. Another officer, a Navy lieutenant colonel, was excused because he said his position on the death penalty had changed and he now opposes the death penalty, telling the court that it is “[n]ot my call to make.”
Mr. al-Nashiri, the Saudi national accused of organizing the October 2000 bombing of the U.S.S. Cole which killed 17 U.S. soldiers, was found competent to stand trial three days before jury selection began. Judge Fitzgerald heard evidence and arguments after defense counsel made him aware that defense experts found Mr. al-Nashiri unfit to stand trial because of the torture he endured at the hands of the CIA. “The commission finds the defense failed to overcome the presumption of competence,” wrote Judge Fitzgerald. “Accordingly, the commission finds the accused is able to understand the nature of the proceedings against him and to conduct or cooperate intelligently in his defense and is therefore competent to stand trial.”
In August 2023, a military judge in Guantánamo Bay overseeing the pretrial capital prosecution of Mr. al-Nashiri excluded his confessions from being used against him at trial because they were the product of torture. Mr. al-Nashiri was waterboarded and subjected to other forms of torture for four years while in CIA custody through a program of “enhanced interrogation.” “Exclusion of such evidence is not without societal costs,” said Judge Colonel Lanny J. Acosta Jr., in a 50-page decision. “However, permitting the admission of evidence obtained by or derived from torture by the same government that seeks to prosecute and execute the accused may have even greater societal costs.” Prosecutors unsuccessfully appealed this decision.
- Bedard, H. (2026, November 16). Two Rare Capital Trials Begin in Buffalo, New York and at Guantánamo Bay. Death Penalty Information Center. Retrieved November 16, 2026, from https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/two-rare-capital-trials-begin-in-buffalo-new-york-and-at-guantánamo-bay
- Bedard, Hayley. “Two Rare Capital Trials Begin in Buffalo, New York and at Guantánamo Bay.” Death Penalty Information Center. November 16, 2026. Accessed November 16, 2026. https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/two-rare-capital-trials-begin-in-buffalo-new-york-and-at-guantánamo-bay.
- Bedard, Hayley. “Two Rare Capital Trials Begin in Buffalo, New York and at Guantánamo Bay.” Death Penalty Information Center, 16 Nov. 2026, https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/two-rare-capital-trials-begin-in-buffalo-new-york-and-at-guantánamo-bay. Accessed 16 Nov. 2026.
Carol Rosenberg, Guantanamo Dispatches: Six Jurors Chosen, 14 More Needed for First Death Penalty Tribunal at Guantanamo Bay, Just Security, November 13, 2026; Jim Fink, Tops shooter’s federal death penalty case inches towards trial date, WBEN, November 13, 2026; Dave McKinley, Woman dismissed as potential juror in Gendron trial after saying recent botched execution had a profound effect on her, WGRZ, November 9, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, Guantanamo Dispatches: Military Judge Accepts First U.S. Navy Officer on Jury in USS Cole Bombing Case, Just Security, November 9, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, A Look Inside Jury Selection in U.S.S. Cole Bombing Case, The New York Times, November 7, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, Guantanamo Dispatches: Slow-Going in Jury Selection for First Capital Terror Trial at Guantanamo Bay, Just Security, November 5, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, Guantanamo Dispatches: Jury Selection Is Underway in the USS Cole Bombing Case, First Capital Case at Guantanamo Bay, Just Security, November 3, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, Jury Selection Begins in First Death-Penalty Case at Guantánamo Bay, The New York Times, November 2, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, Guantanamo Dispatches: Trial Judge Finds Defendant in USS Cole Bombing Case Competent to Face Trial, Just Security, October 30, 2026; Carol Rosenberg, Guantanamo Dispatches: Military Psychiatrist Finds Cole Bombing Case Defendant Competent; Federal Judge Refuses to Intervene, Just Security, October 17, 2026. Natalie Calzetoni & WHAM Staff, Jury selection begins in federal death penalty trial of Buffalo Tops mass shooter, WHAM, October 13, 2026.