Entries by Death Penalty Information Center
News
Jan 13, 2010
U.S. Supreme Court: Smith v. Spisak
On January 12, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in Smith v. Spisak. After Frank Spisak was sentenced to death in Ohio and his initial appeals were denied, he filed a habeas corpus petition claiming that: 1) the jury instructions and verdict forms used at his trial unconstitutionally required the jury to be unanimous in choosing any mitigating factors; and 2) his attorney’s closing argument was so inadequate as to…
Read MoreNews
Jan 12, 2010
Death Penalty Use in Louisiana Has Sharply Declined
Louisiana has seen a steep decline in executions compared to previous decades, with only three executions in the last ten years. This is in stark contrast to the eight men who were electrocuted within the span of 11 weeks in 1987, and it follows a nationwide trend of declining executions and imposition of death…
Read MoreNews
Jan 11, 2010
EDITORIALS: “Death Penalty System ‘Irretrievably Broken’ ”
A recent editorial in the Charlotte Observer in North Carolina cited the American Law Institute’s decision in 2009 to separate itself from the death penalty system as another reason for the state to abolish the practice. The ALI, whose model death penatly standards were instrumental in the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to allow the reinstatement of capital punishment in 1976, has recently disavowed its own recommendations because the…
Read MoreNews
Jan 08, 2010
BOOKS: “Media and Criminal Justice: The CSI Effect”
“Media and Criminal Justice: The CSI Effect,” is a new book by Dennis J. Stevens, illustrating how television programs and media coverage affect public perception of criminal justice. The author, who teaches at the University of North Carolina-Charlotte and Belmont Abbey College, maintains that television shows like “CSI” can give the false impression that all crimes are easily solved through advanced forensic science. The author also addresses the problem of wrongful…
Read MoreNews
Jan 07, 2010
NEW VOICES: American Police Beat Reports “Death penalty comes with a hefty price tag”
A recent article in the American Police Beat highlights the concerns that police chiefs have with the costs and ineffectiveness of capital punishment. The article notes, “The problem, according to the police chiefs is the fact that capital punishment is costing states hundreds of millions of dollars for relatively few executions and nothing in the way of crime deterrence… Hiring more police officers, fighting drug abuse, longer prison sentences and improved…
Read MoreNews
Jan 06, 2010
BOOKS: “Anatomy of an Execution”
A new book authored by Todd Peppers and Laura Trevvett Anderson, “Anatomy of An Execution,” follows the story of Douglas Christopher Thomas, a juvenile offender who was executed in Virginia in 2000. Thomas was convicted of a double homicide in 1990 and sentenced to death in 1991. He was one of the last juveniles put to death before the U.S. Supreme Court ruled the execution of those under the age of 18 at the time of their crime to be unconstitutional in 2005…
Read MoreNews
Jan 05, 2010
OPINION: “Kill the Death Penalty”
The editor of the editorial page of the Palm Beach Post recently called for an end to the death penalty in Florida. Citing DPIC’s recent report on the costs of the death penalty, Randy Schultz notes that, “Every objective study shows that life imprisonment costs much less than sentencing someone to death.” “Money,” he writes, “drives the new debate in Florida about criminal justice.” In 2009, the state legislature declined the $3…
Read MoreNews
Jan 04, 2010
EDITORIALS: “Denial of Death: Time to End Capital Punishment”
An editorial in the Salt Lake Tribune recently called for an end to capital punishment, stating that “the legal, moral and practical arguments against capital punishment have evolved from sound to unassailable” since the punishment was reinstated over 30 years ago. The editorial points to the fallibility of the system as a major concern, citing the Death Penalty Information Center’s report that nine inmates have been exonerated and released from death row in…
Read MoreNews
Dec 31, 2009
ARBITRARINESS: Different Outcomes in Similar Murder Cases in Tennessee
Gaile Owens (pictured) and Mary Winkler are two women who committed similar crimes under similar circumstances in Tennessee. Both women suffered from abuse from the spouses they killed, and both were examined by the same psychologist, twenty years apart. The psychologist said both women suffered from battered woman’s syndrome. Mary Winkler confronted her husband with a shotgun and shot him in the back in 2006. Gaile Owens hired a stranger to…
Read MoreNews
Dec 31, 2009
STUDIES: Researchers Find “No Empirical Support” for Deterrence Theory
Researchers from the University of Texas at Dallas recently published a study on whether executions deter homicides using state panel date and employing well-known econometric procedures for panel analysis. The authors found “no empirical support for the argument that the existence or application of the death penalty deters prospective offenders from committing homicide.” The study was published in the journal of Criminology and Public Policy and authored by Tomislav…
Read More