After Debbie Carter was raped and murdered in Ada, Oklahoma in 1982, police and prosecutors told her cousin, Christy Sheppard (pictured) that Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz were guilty of the crime. In 1988, Williamson was convicted and sentenced to death; Fritz received a life sentence. Eleven years later, the pair were exonerated when DNA testing excluded them as perpetrators and pointed to another man who had once been a suspect. Sheppard, now a criminal justice counselor and victim advocate in Ada, recently shared the story of her experience learning that Williamson and Fritz were actually innocent. “The guilt has been awful,” she said. “It is horrible to think that you prayed, wished, helped and condoned to bring harm to someone else and then to find out that it wasn’t deserved and later learn what they went through.” Sheppard said her family was shocked, “It was like being in a Twilight Zone. It fit nothing we knew to be true.” The experience changed her views on the death penalty, which she had previously supported. “In theory, it seems like that’s the way it ought to be: The punishment fits the crime. But when you pick it apart, it’s just a mess,” she said. Sheppard is serving on the recently-announced Oklahoma Death Penalty Review Commission, and is also campaigning on behalf of Retain a Just Nebraska, a group working to defeat a ballot initiative that would reverse that state’s legislative repeal of the death penalty.
(D. Hendee, “Death penalty opponent says her ‘guilt was awful’ after men convicted of cousin’s murder were proven innocent,” Omaha World-Herald, April 1, 2016.) See Victims and Innocence.
Innocence
Oct 23, 2024
The Limitations of DNA Evidence in Innocence Cases
Innocence
Oct 11, 2024
