In high-profile cases in Sudan and Saudi Arabia, human rights advocates are protesting the threatened use of the death penalty against women for resisting oppression. In the Sudan, prosecutors are seeking to reinstate the death sentence against Noura Hussein (pictured), a teen girl forced into marriage who killed her abusive husband as he tried to rape her. The Saudi Arabian government is seeking the death penalty against Israa al-Ghomgham, an activist who has sought equal rights for Shiite Muslims. The two cases illustrate a worldwide pattern in the use of capital punishment against women who defy cultural gender norms. Hussein, now 19 years old, was forced into marriage at age 16. She fled the marriage, but was tricked into returning by her own family. When she refused to have sex with her husband, he enlisted several cousins to hold her down while he raped her. When he attempted to rape her again the next day, she stabbed him to death. Hussein’s family turned her in to the authorities, and she was tried and sentenced to death in May 2018. After an international campaign on her behalf, a Sudanese court reduced Hussein’s conviction to manslaughter, sentenced her to five years imprisonment, and fined her. State prosecutors are appealing the decision and seek to have her death sentence reinstated. Yasmeen Hassan of the human rights group Equality Now called the Sudan “an extremely patriarchal place [where] gender norms are very strongly enforced.” She said Sudan permits arranged marriages for girls as young as age 10, “there’s legal guardianship of men over women, women are told you have to walk a straight and narrow line and don’t transgress.” Amnesty International spokesperson Seif Magango called the use of the death penalty against Hussein “an intolerable act of cruelty.” Condemning a girl for “killing her rapist husband in self-defence,” she said, demonstrates the “failure of the authorities to tackle child marriage, forced marriage and marital rape.” Hussein’s family has fled their home, fearing reprisal from the victim’s family. The victim’s father told a Sudanese newspaper that, even if Hussein is executed, they will still seek revenge, because she killed a man, and women are not equal to men. Saudi Arabia, known for its oppression of women, has recently begun a crackdown on women’s right’s activists. While the Kingdom has often used the death penalty against political dissidents, trying them in terrorism courts notorious for the denial of due process, Human Rights Watch reports that al-Ghomgham is the first female activist to face execution for her human rights-related work. “Any execution is appalling,” said Sarah Leah Whitson, Middle East director at Human Rights Watch, “but seeking the death penalty for activists like Israa al-Ghomgham, who are not even accused of violent behavior, is monstrous.” The organization warned that the action sets a “dangerous precedent for other women activists currently behind bars.”
The pattern of executing women who break gender expectations has been identified and examined by death-penalty researchers. Dr. Mary Atwell, author of three books on capital punishment, explained: “[F]or the state to put somebody to death in our name, we have to see them as ‘other’ in some way … and I think that’s even more true with a woman. You have to see her as not just doing things that are violent and cruel, but as particularly outside the expectations of what a woman should do.” That is why, she says, in cases in the U.S. in which women are sentenced to death and executed, prosecutors and the press “played up to a great extent” that “these were women who stepped outside the norms of gendered expectations.”
(David D. Kirkpatrick, Saudi Arabia Seeks the Death Penalty for Female Activist, The New York Times, August 22, 2018; Saudi Prosecution Seeks Death Penalty for Female Activist, Human Rights Watch, August 21, 2018; Zeinab Mohammed Salih, Sudan teen who killed rapist husband faces new calls for death penalty, The Guardian, August 24, 2018; Noura Hussein: Sentenced to death in Sudan for killing ‘rapist husband’, BBC News, May 10, 2018.) See International and Women. Listen to the Discussions With DPIC podcast, Women and the Death Penalty, with Dr. Mary Atwell.
International
Jun 05, 2024
